| | 1 | Name: | Charles E. Anthon | | | Year Elected: | 1868 | | | Residency: | Resident | | | Living? : |
Deceased
| | | Death Date: | 6/-/1883 | | | | |
| 2 | Name: | William M. Canby | | | Year Elected: | 1868 | | | Residency: | Resident | | | Living? : |
Deceased
| | | Birth Date: | 1831 | | | Death Date: | 3/10/04 | | | | |
| 3 | Name: | Frederic Graff | | | Year Elected: | 1868 | | | Residency: | Resident | | | Living? : |
Deceased
| | | Death Date: | 3/30/1890 | | | | |
| 4 | Name: | Ulysses S. Grant | | | Year Elected: | 1868 | | | Residency: | Resident | | | Living? : |
Deceased
| | | Death Date: | 7/23/1885 | | | | |
| 5 | Name: | Traill Green | | | Year Elected: | 1868 | | | Residency: | Resident | | | Living? : |
Deceased
| | | | |
| 6 | Name: | Samuel J. Gummere | | | Year Elected: | 1868 | | | Residency: | Resident | | | Living? : |
Deceased
| | | | |
| 7 | Name: | Othniel Marsh | | | Year Elected: | 1868 | | | Residency: | Resident | | | Living? : |
Deceased
| | | Birth Date: | 1831 | | | Death Date: | 3/18/1899 | | | | |
| 8 | Name: | Edward Rhoads | | | Year Elected: | 1868 | | | Residency: | Resident | | | Living? : |
Deceased
| | | Birth Date: | 1842 | | | Death Date: | 1/15/1871 | | | | |
| 9 | Name: | Edward Shippen | | | Year Elected: | 1868 | | | Residency: | Resident | | | Living? : |
Deceased
| | | Death Date: | 6/16/11 | | | | |
| 10 | Name: | Joseph B. Townsend | | | Year Elected: | 1868 | | | Residency: | Resident | | | Living? : |
Deceased
| | | | |
| |